Thin Ice Page 2

  Pummeled by a gust of icy wind, Christy whooshed into the crowded Panera, muttering an apology as she jostled the elderly gent who’d stopped to remove his gloves.

  He steadied himself on a trash bin topped with a stack of empty trays. “No problem, young lady. Mother Nature is pitching a fit tonight, isn’t she?”

  “Yes.” His amiable comment deserved a reply, but she wasn’t in the mood for smiles—or chitchat. Not when she was getting ready to meet an FBI agent . . . and tell him a story he would undoubtedly find farfetched.

  But the letter in her pocket was very real.

  And very, very scary.

  The door opened again, giving her an excuse to move away. She took it.

  From the edge of the dining area, she surveyed the room. There were only a few empty tables, and she claimed one in the center, beside the fireplace. An older couple, two teens doing homework, and a woman engrossed in a bestselling thriller occupied the adjacent tables. None of them seemed suspicious. Besides, no one other than the FBI agent knew about this meeting. And as far as she could tell, no one had followed her here.

  She shrugged out of her jacket, draped it over the back of her chair, and perched on the edge of the seat. Wrapping her fingers around the computer case in her lap, she held on tight.

  What if she’d made a mistake by going to the authorities?

  The knot that had been lodged in the pit of her stomach since she’d made the call tightened. If this decision turned out to be wrong, the consequences would be dire. That much had been clear.

  Yet she wasn’t equipped to deal with a kidnapper. She needed the kind of resources law enforcement could provide.

  Talk about being caught between the proverbial rock and a hard place.

  She pried one hand off the case and tucked her hair behind her ear. She could have hung up while the operator transferred her to McGregor. In fact, she almost had. She could also have severed the connection at any point during her conversation with the agent. He didn’t know her name, and using a pay phone had allowed her to keep her options open.

  But the man had sounded confident and professional, with a subtle take-charge, I’m-in-control manner that reeked of competence.

  All of which had convinced her to take the leap.

  Now it was too late for second thoughts. He’d be here any minute. All she could do was hope she hadn’t misjudged him.

  And pray she wasn’t making a fatal mistake.

  So that was his auburn-haired mystery caller.

  From his seat at a corner table that offered a panoramic view of the eatery, Lance did a quick assessment as the woman claimed a table. Early thirties. Slender. Five-five, five-six. Model-like cheekbones. Flawless complexion. Full lips. Classic profile.

  In other words, the lady was gorgeous.

  And very nervous.

  It didn’t take an FBI agent—or former Delta Force operator—to recognize that the taut line of her shoulders, the clenched fingers, and the lower lip caught between her teeth spelled tension in capital letters.

  He took another sip of his coffee and scanned the crowded restaurant. Thanks to that striking hair, he’d spotted her the minute she stepped inside the door—and no one had followed her in. Nor was anyone watching her . . . except him. Whatever worries she’d had about someone seeing them meet appeared to be groundless.

  But he’d give it ten or fifteen minutes to be on the safe side.

  By 7:05, the woman was jiggling her foot and checking her watch every thirty seconds. She had to be wondering if she’d been stood up . . . and he was tempted to put her mind at ease. But he’d learned long ago not to let pretty women influence his judgment on the job.

  Off the job . . .

  His lips twitched. As his older and younger brothers would be the first to remind him, he wasn’t immune to the charms of an attractive female in his personal life.

  Then again, neither were Mac and Finn.

  Must be in the McGregor genes—though Mac’s newly engaged status meant the St. Louis dating field was his until Finn showed up on his next leave.

  At 7:12, the woman rose and reached for her coat.

  His cue.

  After one more sweep of the café, he slid from behind the table, left his jacket draped over the chair, and wove among the seated diners.

  “Don’t leave yet.”

  She gasped and spun toward him, her face a shade paler than when she’d entered.

  “Sorry. I didn’t mean to startle you.” He leaned closer and dropped his voice. “I’d show you my creds, but I know you want to keep this discreet. I’ll do that once we’re seated.”

  She gave a stiff nod and rested one hand on the table she’d been in the process of vacating. “Is this all right?”

  “I claimed a more out-of-the-way spot.” He indicated the corner table he’d just left.

  She frowned at it. “How long have you been here?”

  “Long enough to scope out the place.”

  After a moment, she pasted on a smile, slipped her arm through his, and raised her volume. “It’s good to see you again.”

  He could tell her she didn’t need to follow through with the friends-getting-together act for the benefit of anyone who might be watching, since no one was. And he’d get around to that in a minute.

  But why not enjoy the sweet scent tickling his nose and the pressure of her graceful fingers on his arm until they got back to his table?

  Too bad the trip was so short.

  Once they arrived, he indicated a chair at a right angle to his and held it as she sat. After retaking his seat against the wall, he again scanned the interior.

  Still clear.

  No one appeared to be the least interested in their meeting.

  Redirecting his attention to her, he pulled out his creds and laid them on the table. “You weren’t followed here. Or if you were, no one followed you in.”

  Her artificial smile faded as she cast a nervous glance around the room, then skimmed his ID. “Are you certain?”

  “Yes.”

  She exhaled, and some of the stiffening in her shoulders dissolved. “I didn’t think so, but I’m glad to have that confirmed by an expert.”

  “Did you want to get anything to eat or drink while we talk?”

  “As long as we don’t need to keep up a social pretense, I’ll just grab a cup of water.”

  Before he could offer to get it for her, she slipped out of her seat and headed toward the drink dispenser.

  He watched as she wove through the crowd with a lithe, natural grace. Like that ballet dancer he’d dated in Washington, DC. The one with the legs that went on forever.

  His gaze dipped. Hard to tell for sure, with those jeans—but he had a feeling this woman might give the ballet dancer some serious competition in the legs department.

  Which was not the most professional train of thought under the circumstances.

  Get your act together, McGregor. You’re here to talk about a possible kidnapping, not troll for a date.

  Check.

  By the time she retook her seat, he’d reined in his wayward musings and was ready to concentrate on business.

  “Now that you know my name, would you like to share yours?”

  Instead of responding, she lifted the cup to take a sip. When the water sloshed dangerously close to the rim, she flicked him a glance, wrapped both hands around the clear plastic, and tried again.

  The woman was seriously spooked.

  She leaned close enough for him to catch another whiff of that pleasing, fresh fragrance. “My name is Christy Reed. I’m the director of youth programs for a municipal recreation center in St. Louis County.” She named the city.

  Based on what he could remember from his review of local maps, that was one of the closer-in suburbs. Not far from the location of the public phone she’d used to call him earlier.

  “You mentioned kidnapping during our phone conversation.”

  “Yes.” She swallowed. Crumpled a paper napk
in. “Look, I’m taking a huge risk by trusting you. But I need experts on this. I can’t lose my sister twice.” Her voice rasped on the last word and she averted her head, bending to pull her laptop out of the carrying case.

  Lose her sister twice?

  What was that supposed to mean?

  She angled the laptop his direction, a shimmer of tears in her eyes. “This is just a cover while we talk.” She lifted the lid. “That’s why I called you.”

  He glanced down. An envelope was lying on the keyboard, addressed by hand to the woman beside him. Next to it was a blank sheet of paper. Both had been placed in plastic bags.

  Like she was preserving evidence.

  He sent her a quizzical look.

  She scooted her chair closer and locked gazes with him. “Two months ago, my sister, Ginny, was killed in a house fire. She was my only sibling, and we were very close. More than ever after we lost our parents eight months ago in a car accident.”

  Whoa.

  Christy Reed had lost her whole family in the space of six months?

  That was serious trauma. Enough to account for the smoky whisper of shadows under her eyes. Enough to etch those faint lines of strain at the corners of her mouth.

  Enough to push some people over the edge.

  Was she one of them?

  He studied her. “That’s a lot to deal with in a very short time.”

  “Tell me about it.” She rested her left hand on the table beside the computer and clenched her fist. “I try to take it day by day, and I pray a lot. Some days are easier than others. Yesterday wasn’t one of them. Not after this arrived in the mail.” She touched the corner of the plastic-encased envelope.

  “Why was that a problem?”

  Her throat worked again, and she moistened her lips. “Because that’s Ginny’s handwriting.”

  The letter was from the sister who’d died two months ago?

  He checked the postmark. The note had been mailed January 5 from Terre Haute, Indiana. Four days ago.

  But dead people didn’t write letters.

  “I had the same reaction.” At her quiet comment, he turned his head. Intelligent eyes the color of burnished jade met his, steady but anxious. “This is what was inside.” She flipped over the sheet of paper.

  He read the short, typewritten message.

  I took your sister. If you want her back, do not tell anyone about this or call the police. Just wait for furthur orders.

  A typical kidnapping note.

  Except this wasn’t a typical kidnapping scenario. Not by a long shot. For one thing, kidnappers didn’t wait two months to initiate contact. For another, this victim was supposed to be already dead.

  “I know this doesn’t seem to make sense.” Christy drew a shaky breath. “But it could if my sister didn’t die in the fire.”

  He frowned. “Are you telling me they didn’t find her body?”

  “They found a body. It was burned beyond recognition.” Her voice choked, and she swallowed. “Everyone assumed it was her.”

  “Wasn’t there an autopsy?”

  “No. Ginny was a wildlife biologist in the Mark Twain National Forest. She lived on the outskirts of Chandler, a small town just south of Potosi, and the local police didn’t see any need for an autopsy after an investigator from the state fire marshal’s office ruled the fire accidental.”

  “What was the basis for that opinion?”

  “My sister’s house was old and drafty, and she supplemented her furnace with electric heaters downstairs and in her bedroom. According to the investigator, it appeared the one in the bedroom had been too close to the curtains. The window was open, and he reasoned that the wind blew the fabric against the heater, which started the fire. The frame house was old, the wood dry . . .” She lifted one shoulder.

  No matter the apparent cause, an autopsy should have been done. Would have been done by a larger police department.

  And it could still be done—if necessary.

  Lance folded his hands on the table. “Other than this note, do you have any reason to think the body found in your sister’s house belonged to someone else?”

  “No. That’s why the whole thing is so confusing. But this is Ginny’s handwriting. The backward slant, the curlicue at the end of the s, the tail she always added to her capital R’s . . . her penmanship is distinctive.”

  “An expert forger could replicate it.”

  She sucked in a breath. “You think this is some sort of hoax?”

  “It’s possible.”

  “But . . . why would someone do that?”

  “Good question—except look at the flip side. If this isn’t a hoax, someone went to a lot of effort to make it appear your sister died in a fire, including providing a body. Why would someone do that?”

  She shook her head, her distress almost palpable. “I have no idea.”

  “Did your sister have any enemies?”

  “No. Ginny was the sweetest, gentlest . . .” She groped for her water, lifting it with both hands again to take a sip. “Sorry.” She set the cup back down. “Everyone loved Ginny.”

  “Was she married?”

  “No.”

  “Was there an ex-husband or boyfriend or ex-boyfriend in the picture?”

  “No. She didn’t date much, and she lived alone.”

  “How old was she?”

  “Thirty.”

  He shot her a skeptical look. “Thirty years old and no significant ex-love interests?”

  “She worked long hours, often in the woods communing with nonhuman species, and lived in the middle of nowhere. There weren’t many opportunities to meet eligible men.”

  “Even so, most people don’t make it to thirty without logging a few failed relationships—and those often leave bad feelings in their wake on one or both sides.”

  “Ginny never dated anyone long enough to generate hurt feelings when she stopped seeing them.”

  “As far as you know.”

  Her chin lifted a notch. “We were close. If there was a man in her life, she’d have told me. Not everyone is interested in putting notches on their belt, Agent McGregor. And not everyone ends relationships with bad feelings. It’s dangerous to jump to conclusions about others based on personal experience.”

  Ouch.

  Still, whether or not he liked her inference, it did tell him two things.

  There was nothing wrong with her mind. The FBI might get its share of fruitcake calls, but this woman was a clear, analytical thinker not inclined to flights of fancy—or overreaction.

  She was also becoming defensive, which would get them nowhere.

  Better to ease off and circle back to this topic later or she might shut down.

  He took a sip of coffee and set his cup off to the side. “Why don’t you tell me about the fire?”

  Her posture drooped, and she dropped her chin to stare at the melting ice in her cup. “It happened on a Friday night. I’d been planning to drive out on Saturday to spend the weekend with Ginny. But when she didn’t answer her phone or return my calls, I got worried and went out after work. The whole house was in flames when I arrived about nine forty-five. I got there right before it . . . collapsed.”

  Christy Reed had watched the tragedy unfold.

  The lady beside him had had some very tough breaks.

  Out of nowhere, an urge to weave his fingers through hers swept over him, the impulse so powerful his hand was already halfway to its destination when he caught himself, forcibly shifting direction to grab his coffee cup instead.

  Keep your mind on the case, McGregor, not the woman. You’re here to investigate, not console.

  He took a sip of his coffee and set the cup down. “Any particular reason you’d worry because your sister wasn’t responding to your calls?”

  “Yes. Ginny was having a hard time dealing with our parents’ deaths. She wasn’t eating or sleeping enough, and it was beginning to impact her ability to function at work. She finally resorted to taking over-the-c
ounter sleeping aids. That worried me, even though she was responsible about it.”

  “Did you tell this to the police?”

  “Yes. Since she was found in bed, they concluded she must have taken some pills and slept through the fire. Otherwise, she should have smelled the smoke and called for help. As it was, a passing motorist sounded the alarm after he spotted flames on the roof. But it was too late. Ginny never made it out. At least I didn’t think so, until that came.” She touched the edge of one of the plastic-encased documents.

  He pulled a notebook out of his pocket. “I’ll get copies of the police and fire investigator’s reports tomorrow morning.”

  She leaned down, removed a manila file folder from her laptop case, and handed it to him. “Done. I asked for copies of everything . . . never knowing I’d need them for such a bizarre reason. I assumed you’d want them.”

  Nope. No problem with this lady’s brain.

  He opened the file and gave the brief, straightforward reports a quick read. It was hard to fault their logic or the conclusions. The pieces all added up to a typical tragic house fire.

  Or they had, until now.

  Unless the note was, indeed, a hoax.

  He was back to the line of questioning Christy hadn’t liked.

  “I asked before if your sister had any enemies.” He approached the topic with more caution this go-round, choosing his words with care. “If the note turns out to be some sort of sick joke, it would suggest this is more about you than her. Do you have any enemies?”

  “No.” Her answer was immediate—and firm. “And I’ll save you from asking the next question. I’ve had one serious relationship in my life. It ended four years ago, but we parted on friendly terms. It’s hard to fault a man for choosing the divine over the human.”

  He squinted at her. “What does that mean?”

  She gave him a wry look. “He was Catholic, and after a lot of soul searching, he decided he had a calling to the priesthood.”

  A former boyfriend who was a priest.

  Not a likely suspect.

  He closed the file. “I’m sorry if I offended you with my earlier questions on this subject—but romantic relationships gone south are often the impetus for crime.”